Since January, people in Utah have been able to renew some prescriptions through Doctronic, an AI service admitted to the state’s regulatory sandbox, a program that lets the state set aside certain rules so a company can test a new technology. The patient confirms she lives in Utah, chooses a medicine from a list of about 190, including drugs for blood pressure, diabetes, asthma and cholesterol, answers a few questions, and pays $4. Under the pilot’s design, Doctronic’s physicians review the first 250 requests in each group of medicines before anything is sent, and the next 1,000 afterward. Then the system works on its own and calls a clinician only when its own rules say so.
Convenience is real. A renewal that takes a minute matters to someone without a car, without time off work, or without a doctor nearby. The question is what else the old, slower renewal was doing.
2,317 requests, fewer than 600 completed by the AI
Data Doctronic reported to the state, obtained by the Utah Investigative Journalism Project and published by KUER on October 22, show that among 2,317 refill requests from January through September fewer than 600 were completed by the AI. The company has said publicly that its results show 97% agreement with human doctors and no adverse events. Those figures are its own. The state is only now reviewing them, through 10 volunteer clinicians rather than an official auditor. Among the reviewed renewals, 13 were flagged for safety concerns in which both reviewing physicians disagreed with the AI.
What a refill used to include
A renewal is rarely just a signature. “Many times when I see people after six months I find that their medical history or situation has changed,” Alan Smith, the family physician who chairs Utah’s medical licensing board, told the Associated Press, speaking for himself. “Just because something was prescribed before does not mean it’s appropriate now.” Some medicines on the list, such as levothyroxine for the thyroid and sacubitril-valsartan for heart failure, need blood tests to be used safely. Writing in JAMA Internal Medicine, researchers from MIT, McGill, Johns Hopkins, Stanford and Beth Israel Deaconess note that public materials do not show the system can see a patient’s laboratory results or physician notes. “Rules cannot escalate on data the system does not see.”
5 parties, and no one clearly answerable
When a physician renews a medicine and is wrong, the same authors write, the line of responsibility is short: a named clinician, a license, a board, a malpractice carrier. Under automated renewal, it runs through the developer, a contracted physician who reviewed an earlier batch of requests, the state agency, the pharmacy, and the patient who clicked through the terms of service. Those terms, they report, deny that the service creates a physician–patient relationship, cap damages and require individual arbitration, and the state’s agreement relieves the company of the usual duty to keep and provide each patient’s medical record. The company does carry malpractice insurance, and the state’s agreement preserves patients’ legal remedies; the terms may still make them hard to use.
“We have crossed a threshold in terms of giving something that is not human a medical license, whether or not we want to call it that,” Eric Bressman of the University of Pennsylvania told the AP.
What it changes for you
Services like this will spread; the company plans to expand to other states. Before you use one, for yourself or for a parent, ask three questions. Who looks at my request, and when, before it is sent or only afterward? What can the system see: my recent blood tests, my other medicines, my doctor’s notes? And what do I give up when I accept the terms, including access to my own record? A refill that arrives in a minute is also a visit you did not have. Make sure you still have the visit.
When a machine renews your medicine and it was the wrong call, who will take your complaint?
Sources. Jaiswal N, Gorijavolu R, Hernandez-Boussard T, Celi LA. When an Algorithm Renews a Prescription. JAMA Internal Medicine, published online August 31, 2026. doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2026.3480 · “Utah’s AI prescription pilot mindset is more tech bro than doctor, critics say,” Utah Investigative Journalism Project and KUER, October 22, 2026 · Associated Press, “Is AI ready to take over your prescriptions? Doctors are wary of Utah’s automated refill program,” July 6, 2026 (as published by ABC News) · State of Utah, regulatory sandbox agreement with Doctronic
Related. Who answers when the machine holds the license? · Who can stop the machine?

